Where to Sell Items in Red Dead Online

Making money is a key aspect of Red Dead Online, and one of the best ways to earn cash is by selling items you’ve gathered across your adventures. Different merchants throughout the world will buy various goods, and each merchant offers different rewards for trade milestones. Here’s everything you need to know to sell your items in the game, maximize your profits, and complete trade awards along the way.

Note: There is a Gold Belt Buckle Trade award for selling items at each of the three shops listed below, offering easy XP as a reward.

Sell Items to a Fence

Fences specialize in buying stolen or illicit goods and offer a variety of high-value items for sale. If you’ve looted jewelry, watches, gold bars, or other valuables, a Fence is the place to go. Selling these goods will not only give you cash but also contribute toward specific trade awards.

Items to Sell to a Fence

• Jewelry: Necklaces, rings, bracelets, and other high-value items.
• Watches: Pocket watches, wristwatches, and other timepieces.
• Buckles: Various belt buckles, including collectible designs.
• Gold Bars: High-value items worth a considerable sum.

Trade Award Milestones

• Sell 10, 50, 100, 500, and 1000 valuables to earn corresponding Gold Belt Buckle rewards.

Fence Locations

You can find Fences in several locations across Red Dead Online, making them relatively easy to access:

• Saint Denis
• Van Horn Trading Post
• Thieves Landing
• Rhodes

Selling Tips

• Higher Returns for Gold Bars: Gold Bars fetch a high price at Fences, making them a great target for your loot collection.
• Best for Stolen Goods: If you’ve taken valuables from loot piles, trains, or the bodies of your fallen enemies, Fences are your go-to merchants. They’re perfect for turning ill-gotten gains into legitimate currency.

Sell Animal Products to a Butcher

Butchers are the place to sell your animal-related goods. Whether you’re a hunter or a trapper, any pelts, meats, and other animal products you collect will fetch a decent sum at Butchers. These merchants are scattered across the map, and each will offer a different price depending on what you’re selling.

Items to Sell to a Butcher

• Meat: The meat of animals like cows, pigs, pronghorns, and other hunted animals.
• Pelts and Skins: Valuable animal pelts, such as those from deer, wolves, bears, and more.
• Feathers: From birds such as geese, ducks, and eagles.

Trade Award Milestones

• Sell 10, 50, 100, 500, and 1000 animal products to complete the associated awards.

Butcher Locations

You can sell your animal goods at Butchers in the following locations:

• Saint Denis
• Strawberry
• Valentine
• Blackwater
• Rhodes

Selling Tips

• Hunt Pronghorns and Deer: These animals are among the best for hunting as they provide valuable meat and pelts.
• Skinning for Extra Value: Be sure to skin your animals to maximize the price of your pelts, and don’t forget to sell their horns, antlers, and other parts for additional cash.
• Meat Quality Matters: Higher-quality meat and pelts, especially those from perfect animals, will sell for more.

Sample Prices:

• A perfect pronghorn carcass can fetch up to $12.
• Deer antlers and pelts also add significant value to your earnings.

Sell Herbs to a Doctor

While the prices aren’t as lucrative as selling animal goods or valuables, herbs can still contribute to your overall earnings. Doctors are interested in the various herbs and flowers you can pick while exploring the world of Red Dead Online. It may not make you a fortune, but it’s a good way to make a bit of extra cash while exploring.

Items to Sell to a Doctor

• Common Herbs: Violet Snowdrop, Creeping Thyme, and Currants.
• Special Herbs: Red Sage (found primarily in Chuparosa and other areas).

Trade Award Milestones

• Sell 5, 25, 50, 75, and 100 herbs to achieve rewards.

Doctor Locations

You can find Doctors in the following towns:

• Valentine
• Saint Denis

Selling Tips

• Herb Locations: Herbs are usually found near water sources and can often be found in clusters. Explore areas near rivers and streams to gather them.
• Limited Earnings: While herb sales are a reliable source of income, they’re not as profitable as hunting or looting. Still, selling herbs helps you complete trade awards and contributes to your overall earnings.
• Best for Completing Trade Awards: If you’re working on achieving milestones for “Selling Herbs to a Doctor,” this is a straightforward way to grind out progress.

Items That Cannot Be Sold

While many items in Red Dead Online can be sold to various merchants, there are some that can’t be sold at all. Here’s a list of items that are currently unsellable in the game:

• Horses: You can’t sell your personal horse.
• Alcohol: Bottles of alcohol, whether collected or looted, cannot be sold.
• Food: Items like canned goods, fish, and other food items cannot be sold.

Note: These restrictions may change in future updates, so check back regularly for any changes that Rockstar may make.

Additional Tips for Maximizing Your Earnings

• Check Prices Regularly: Prices may fluctuate depending on in-game events, updates, or market conditions, so be sure to visit different merchants to compare prices.
• Visit Different Shops for the “Visit 50 Shops” Award: Simply entering shops counts towards your achievement progress, so make sure to swing by various merchants while you’re out hunting or looting.
• Collect Gold Nuggets: Gold Nuggets are a great way to make quick cash. Look for them while exploring, and aim to collect 100 for the associated trade award.

Selling items in Red Dead Online isn’t just a way to make money—it’s also an essential part of completing trade awards and progressing through the game. Whether you’re a seasoned hunter, a bandit, or someone who enjoys picking flowers, the various merchants in the world will provide opportunities to cash in on your finds.

By knowing where to sell specific items, focusing on trade award milestones, and taking advantage of item-specific selling tips, you’ll be able to maximize your profits and make your mark as a savvy entrepreneur in the world of Red Dead Online.

Thoughts on our where to sell items in Red Dead Online guide? Drop them in the comments below.