Honor Among Horse Thieves Guide – Red Dead Online

Honor Among Horse Thieves Guide
To start the Honor Among Horse Thieves mission, playthrough the tutorial until the C appears on your map.

When you begin playing Red Dead Online, you will go through a bit of a tutorial which runs you through the various systems at play in the game’s online. One new addition to the online mode is story missions. These missions play out like those in the singleplayer and can be completed for XP and other bonuses. The first story mission you will receive is from Clay Davies. Below is our Honor Among Horse Thieves guide. Note: Red Dead Online is currently in Beta. 

Starting the Honor Among Horse Thieves Mission

Honor Among Horse Thieves Guide

To start the Honor Among Horse Thieves mission, playthrough the tutorial until the C appears on your map.

You will naturally progress to the Honor Among Horse Thieves mission by playing through the opening tutorial of Red Dead Online. Once you’ve made your way far enough you will be prompted to see Clay Davies (C on your map). When you visit Davies you will be prompted to start the mission. This mission can be completed with 1 – 4 players.

Go to the Woolen Mill

To steal the horses for Clay Davies, you need to go to the location specified by him. The location he specifies is called the Woolen Mill. You can find the Woolen Mill in Rhodes. To get there mount up and follow the mission way point. When you reach Rhodes you will want to get off your horse outside the Woolen Mill since there are a number of enemies in the area.

Steal a Horse

Steal a Horse

In the stable at Woolen Mill you will find a horse you can steal.

How you go about completing this next objective is largely up to you. Since the game is multiplayer, the players I was with went in guns blazing. Once everyone in Gray Woolen Mill is killed, approach the Stables to the east. Inside the Stables you will find a horse. Approach the horse, calm it, then get on it.

Take the Horse to the Stable

Once you’ve stolen the horse, your objective will change to taking the horse to the Stable. The Stable we will take the horse to is in Saint Denis. As you make the long ride you will be attacked by a number of enemies on horseback. Be sure to have your weapon at the ready. Once you reach the Stable in Saint Denis you will have completed the Honor Among Horse Thieves story mission. For completing this mission you earn the following:

  • The horse you stole.
  • $14.40.
  • Access to Stable services.
  • XP.

That’s all for this guide. Keep it locked to HTR for more Red Dead Online coverage.

Next Online Mission: The Right Side of the Tracks.

Thoughts on our Honor Among Horse Thieves guide? Drop them in The Pit below.


A lifelong gamer who has devoted the last six years to the creation and development of "Hold To Reset," a website tailored by gamers for gamers. Yell your hot takes at him on X.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.