Honor Among Horse Thieves Guide – Red Dead Online

by enricofairme · Published November 27, 2018 10:51 AM · Updated March 7, 2025 12:12 PM

In the stable at Woolen Mill you will find a horse you can steal.

In Red Dead Online, the mission “Honor Among Horse Thieves” introduces players to horse rustling and stable mechanics as part of the tutorial section. Here’s a detailed guide to help you navigate and complete this mission effectively.

Starting the Mission

Honor Among Horse Thieves map location. — To start the Honor Among Horse Thieves mission, playthrough the tutorial until the C appears on your map.

After completing the introductory tutorial, you’ll receive a prompt to meet Clay Davies, a known horse thief. His location is marked with a ‘C’ on your map. Approach Clay to initiate the mission. This mission supports 1 to 4 players, allowing for solo or cooperative play.

Objective: Steal Horses from the Woolen Mill

Stable at the Woolen Mill. — You need to make your way to the Woolen Mill to steal horses.

Clay tasks you with stealing horses from the Woolen Mill near Rhodes.

Ride to the Woolen Mill: Mount your horse and follow the waypoint. As you near the mill, dismount and move cautiously—enemies are guarding the area.
Choose Your Approach: Take out the enemies in a firefight or sneak past them to avoid detection.
Steal a Horse: Head to the stables on the east side of the mill. Approach a horse calmly to keep it from spooking, then mount up.

Objective: Deliver the Horse to the Stable

Taking the Horse to the Stable. — Once you have the horse, take it to the Stable in Saint Denis.

Horse outside of the stable. — Once you have the horse, take it to the Stable in Saint Denis.

Once mounted, your next task is to deliver the horse to the stable in Saint Denis.

Prepare for Ambushes: During your ride, be prepared for potential ambushes by enemy riders. Keep your weapons ready and stay vigilant.
Reach Saint Denis: Follow the designated route to the stable. Upon arrival, a cutscene will play, marking the mission’s completion.

Rewards for Completion

Successfully completing the mission grants:

A New Horse: The horse you delivered becomes yours, providing a reliable mount for future endeavors.
Monetary Reward: Earn approximately $14.40 for your efforts.
Stable Access: Gain access to stable services, allowing you to manage and customize your horses.
Experience Points (XP): Accumulate XP to progress your character’s abilities and unlock new features.

Post-Mission: Establishing Your Camp

After completing the mission, you’ll be directed to meet JB Cripps at your new camp. Here, you’ll learn about camp management, daily fees, and opportunities for future missions. Cripps will also inform you about Horley’s message to meet him in Blackwater, setting the stage for subsequent adventures.

With the horses delivered and your journey in Red Dead Online just beginning, it’s time to take on your next mission. In The Right Side of the Tracks, you’ll continue working for Horley as you prove yourself in the West. Ready for the next challenge? Check out our The Right Side of the Tracks guide to keep your adventure moving forward.

Thoughts on our Honor Among Horse Thieves guide? Drop them in the comments below.