10 Mysterious Locations You Need to Visit in Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 is packed with secrets, hidden locations, and eerie encounters that add depth to the game’s world. If you love uncovering the strange and unexplained, this guide highlights 10 mysterious locations you need to visit in Red Dead Redemption 2, filled with mystery, treasure, and supernatural phenomena.

1. Meteor House & Meteor Crater

• Location: Northeast of Roanoke Valley

A small cabin in the Roanoke Valley holds a shocking sight—a meteorite has crashed through the roof, leaving a gruesome scene inside. Travel northwest from the house, and you’ll find a massive meteor crater, suggesting that a larger meteor caused this catastrophe.

Why Visit?

• Collectible: You can pick up a meteorite from inside the house and in the crater, which can slightly reduce your Core Drain Rate when carried.
• Lore: One of the few cosmic events referenced in the game, adding a touch of sci-fi to RDR2’s realism.

2. UFO at Hani’s Bethel

• Location: North of Emerald Station

Inside an abandoned shack at Hani’s Bethel, you’ll find rotting corpses and a cryptic note titled Mysterious Sermon. The sermon references an alien voyager who will return for believers “at the second hour under the half moon.”

How to Trigger the UFO Event:

1. Visit the shack during the daytime and read the Mysterious Sermon.
2. Return after 2 AM on a clear night with a half-moon phase.
3. Stay inside the cabin, and a glowing green UFO will appear overhead before quickly vanishing.

Why Visit?

• One of the game’s best Easter eggs.
• Hints at more extraterrestrial activity in RDR2’s world.

3. The Witch’s Cauldron

• Location: North of Ambarino’s “N” on the map

Hidden deep in the woods is a witch’s hut with strange ingredients and an ominous bubbling cauldron. If you interact with the cauldron, Arthur drinks a mysterious potion and immediately passes out, waking up a short distance away.

Why Visit?

• Unique, unexplained supernatural moment.
• No lasting effects, but adds to RDR2’s folklore.

4. Devil’s Cave (Hidden Tunnel)

• Location: West of Hanging Dog Ranch

This deep, dark cave is home to a self-proclaimed Devil. As you enter, a voice echoes through the tunnels, warning you to leave. If you persist, you’ll find a lone man who has lived in isolation for years, calling himself the Devil.

Why Visit?

• Dialogue changes each time you visit.
• A fascinating look at isolation and madness in the Wild West.

5. Manmade Mutant Experiment

• Location: House west of Van Horn Trading Post

An eerie house contains an abandoned experiment—a grotesque manmade mutant attached to the wall. The door is locked, but you can enter by climbing the wagon outside and using the second-floor window.

Why Visit?

• One of the creepiest secrets in the game.
• Raises questions about mad science in the Old West.

6. Robot’s Resting Place

• Location: Northeast of Colter in the Grizzlies

After completing the Marko Dragic Stranger Mission, take the Electric Lantern to a snowy peak in the Grizzlies. The lantern changes color as you get closer to a heartbreaking discovery—Marko Dragic’s abandoned robot, sitting alone in the snow, repeating, “Papa?”

Why Visit?

• A tragic end to a sci-fi storyline.
• Adds to the game’s themes of progress vs. tradition.

7. Derailed Train Wreck

• Location: North of Cotorra Springs

A massive train wreck lies at the bottom of a cliff, filled with valuables. You can carefully climb inside to loot it, though it’s a dangerous descent.

Loot Found Here:

• Gold bars (worth $500 each when sold to a Fence).
• Random lootable items.

Why Visit?

• A hidden treasure trove for early-game cash.
• Ties into RDR2’s environmental storytelling.

8. Bonnie MacFarlane’s Husband’s Grave

• Location: Near MacFarlane’s Ranch (epilogue only)

A single grave with a note reveals that Bonnie MacFarlane’s husband has died, filling in a backstory detail from Red Dead Redemption 1.

Why Visit?

• A tragic callback for RDR1 fans.
• One of the few direct connections between the two games.

9. Strange Man’s Cabin

• Location: Bayall Edge, Lemoyne

This shack features a portrait of the Strange Man (a supernatural figure from RDR1) that paints itself over time. When you reach 100% completion, the painting is finished, and the Strange Man’s reflection can be seen in the mirror, but he never appears in the room.

Why Visit?

• One of the most cryptic mysteries in RDR2.
• References one of the most mysterious characters in the series.

10. Mount Shann’s Mystery

• Location: Big Valley, West Elizabeth

Mount Shann features multiple bizarre elements:

• A mysterious dial-like rock formation at the summit.
• A UFO sighting.
• Strange symbols resembling those in the Strange Man’s cabin.
• Panorama Drawing.

Why Visit?

• Unresolved connections to multiple in-game mysteries.
• One of the most talked-about locations in the RDR2 community.

Red Dead Redemption 2’s world is full of secrets waiting to be discovered. These 10 locations barely scratch the surface of the game’s hidden mysteries, but they offer some of the most unique and eerie encounters.

Thoughts on our 10 mysterious locations you need to visit in Red Dead Redemption 2 guide? Let us hear them in the comments below.