As an outlaw, one must be ready to face death on a daily basis. This is especially true for Dutch and his gang of misfits who are constantly under fire from different factions that want them dead. As you play through the main story, many of the members of the posse will die. After their death these members will be buried in various locations around the world. In total there are 9 grave locations you can visit after you’ve beaten Red Dead Redemption 2. Below I will show you the exact location of each grave in this graves guide. MAJOR SPOILERS BELOW.
You must beat the game before the graves will appear in your world.
When you find a grave, interact with it to pay respects.
The order you visit the graves doesn’t matter.
Finding all 9 Graves accounts for 3.4% total game completion.
Visiting all 9 graves earns the Paying Respects trophy/achievement.
After you complete Red Dead Redemption 2 (see the credits roll), you will have a new addition to your collectables menu called Graves. You will need to visit each one if you want to unlock the Paying Respects trophy/achievement. Here is the description of the Graves Collectables:
“Through bad decisions and bad luck, not everyone will survive this difficult journey. After they pass, pay your respects and find the graves of 9 fallen companions.”
For a more indepth look at each location, check out the information below.
Sean MacGuire Grave Location
Sean MacGuire’s grave can be found to the northwest of Rhodes.
You will find Sean MacGuire’s grave on the east bank of Flat Iron Lake.
The first grave we are going to visit is Sean MacGuire’s. This grave is located to the northwest of Rhodes on a hill along the shoreline of Flat Iron Lake. When you reach the spot located above, you will find the grave of Sean MacGuire. Inspect the grave to pay your respects.
Kieran Duffy Grave Location
Kieran Duffy’s grave can be located to the east of the Braithwaite Manor.
The grave of Kieran Duffy is marked with a tall stone tombstone.
You will find the grave of Kieran Duffy to the east of Braithwaite Manor in Lemoyne. The grave itself is in a large open field near the treeline. Inspect the grave to pay your respects.
Hosea Matthews Grave Location
Both Hosea Matthews and Lenny Summers are buried in this location.
Hosea Matthews grave can be found beside a large tree at the spot indicated on the map.
To find the grave of Hosea Matthews, make your way to the spot pictured just north of Saint Denis (directly east of the Bait Shop on Lagras). The grave can be found beside Lenny Summers grave, close to a large tree. Inspect the grave to pay your respects.
Lenny Summers Grave Location
You will find Lenny Summers grave beside Hosea’s.
Lenny Summers grave can be found in the same spot as Hosea Matthews. Summers’ grave is the one closest to the large tree. Inspect it to pay your respects.
Susan Grimshaw Grave Location
Susan Grimshaw is buried near the Elysian Pool.
You will find Susan Grimshaw’s grave on the cliff above the railway tracks.
Susan Grimshaw’s grave can be found to the northeast of Emerald Station near the Elysian Pool. The grave can be found on the top of the cliffside overlooking the railroad tracks. Inspect the grave to pay your respects.
Arthur Morgan Grave Location
At this exact location you will find the grave of Arthur Morgan.
The grave of Arthur Morgan can be found on the mountain behind the Mysterious Hill Home.
Arthur Morgan’s grave is located east of Bacchus Station near the Mysterious Hill Home. To find the exact location of the grave, make your way up the hillside behind the mysterious house. On the first ridge, you will find Arthur’s grave. Depending on the honor level of your playthrough with Arthur you will see two different animals at the grave site:
Eagle (High honor).
Wolf (Low honor).
Inspect grave to pay your respects and then try not to cry over the death of such a good video game character.
Eagle Flies Grave Location
Eagle Flies is buried on the west banks of the Donner Falls.
You will find the grave of Eagle Flies near the Donner Falls.
The grave of Eagle Flies can be found slightly west of Donner Falls. The grave is in a clearing with direct line of sight to the falls. Inspect the grave to pay your respects to Eagle Flies.
Davey Callander Grave Location
You will find Davey Callander buried in the graveyard here.
Look for the grave facing the wrong way to find Davey.
Davey Callander is buried in the graveyard behind the old church in Colter. Poleter can be located in along the Spider Gorge near Cairn Lake. When you reach the grave, inspect to pay your respects.
Jenny Kirk Grave Location
You will find the Jenny Kirk Grave near the northernmost portion of the map.
The grave for Jenny Kirk is along the river bank of the Spider Gorge.
The final grave, Jenny Kirk’s, can be found to the east of the Glacier along the Spider Gorge. Follow the banks of the river up from Colter until you reach a clearing. In this clearing is Jenny Kirk’s grave. Inspect the grave to pay your respects.
For paying respects at all 9 of the graves, you earn the Paying Respects Trophy/Achievement. That’s all for this guide. Thanks for reading and hope it helped!
Read More: Check out our other Red Dead Redemption 2guides.
Did our Red Dead Redemption 2 Graves Guide help you find every grave? Let us know in The Pit below.