How to Get the Broken Pirate Sword in Red Dead Redemption 2

by enricofairme · Published November 1, 2018 2:53 PM · Updated March 5, 2025 10:29 PM

The Broken Pirate Sword is one of the better melee weapons you can find.

Red Dead Redemption 2 is filled with unique weapons to collect. One of the more interesting and rare ones is the Broken Pirate Sword. This sword is a fun addition to your arsenal. In this guide, we’ll show you exactly how to find it, along with a few additional details that will enhance your gameplay experience.

1. Getting to the Location: Southwest of Saint Denis

Map location Broken Pirate Sword. — To start, make your way to this cluster of three islands.

Where to Go: The Broken Pirate Sword is located on a cluster of small islands southwest of Saint Denis in the Bayou Nwa region. These islands are just off the coast.
Navigating the Area: To find the islands, head south from Saint Denis. Look for the small islands in the bayou. Be careful of alligators swimming around. The swampy waters are home to many dangerous creatures.

2. Finding the Abandoned Boat

Broken Pirate Sword inside boat. — On the island you will find the Broken Pirate Sword inside an abandoned boat.

Look for the Boat: The sword is located on the northernmost island in the cluster. This island is home to an abandoned boat. The boat is stranded on the island’s shore, so be sure to explore the area thoroughly.
Inspect the Boat: Once you’ve found the boat, approach it and look inside. The Broken Pirate Sword will be lodged inside, sticking up from the boat’s floor.

3. Picking Up the Broken Pirate Sword

Grab the Sword: Once you see the sword, interact with it to pick it up. You’ll need to press Triangle/Y on your controller to add it to your inventory. After picking it up, it will also be recorded in your Compendium. This is a useful feature if you’re aiming to complete your collection.

4. What Makes the Broken Pirate Sword Special?

Weapon Description: The Broken Pirate Sword is an old and rare pirate cutlass with a long snapped blade and a golden handguard. Despite its age, it remains a practical weapon for melee combat. It offers a longer reach than many other blades in the game.
Combat Use: The sword’s long reach makes it a useful tool in close-quarters combat. While it may not have the highest damage stats, its extended range can help you land more hits. You can keep enemies at bay with it.

5. Additional Tips

Compendium Entry: After acquiring the sword, it will be documented in your Compendium. This will allow you to learn more about its backstory and significance in the game.
Completing the Weapon Collection: The Broken Pirate Sword is one of 59 weapons you’ll need to collect to complete your weapon collection in Red Dead Redemption 2. It’s a great addition for completionists.

6. Bonus: Pirate Hat and More

Pirate Hat Location: As a fun bonus, if you’re really getting into the pirate theme, there’s also a pirate hat nearby. It is located on a shipwreck. This hat perfectly complements the Broken Pirate Sword and gives you a swashbuckling look!
Alternative to Machete: If you haven’t picked up the Machete yet, the Broken Pirate Sword is a great alternative. It is especially fun if you’re looking for a more unique weapon to wield.

Now that you’ve added the Broken Pirate Sword to your collection, why not explore other unique and hidden weapons in Red Dead Redemption 2? Check out our UFO guide to uncover one of the game’s most mysterious secrets, grab the Viking Hatchet for another rare weapon, or track down the elusive Rare Shotgun for some powerful firepower. These guides will help you make the most out of your journey in the wild west.

Thoughts on our how to get the Broken Pirate Sword in Red Dead Redemption 2 guide? Drop them in the comments below.