Red Dead Redemption 2 Trinkets and Talismans: Complete Guide to Effects, Recipes, and Crafting

In Red Dead Redemption 2, visiting a Fence is an essential part of your journey. Not only can you offload stolen goods, but these shady vendors also sell powerful Red Dead Redemption 2 Trinkets and Talismans that offer valuable perks and buffs. If you want to maximize your efficiency, stay alive longer, and enhance your abilities in the wild, understanding how to obtain and use these unique items is crucial. In this guide, we’ll dive into all the different Fence Trinkets and Talismans, their effects, and how to craft them.
What Are Trinkets and Talismans?
Trinkets and Talismans are special items you can craft at a Fence in Red Dead Redemption 2. They provide passive bonuses to your character or to your horse. While Trinkets are generally easier to craft and provide helpful boosts, Talismans are rarer, require more investment, and provide even stronger buffs. Let’s take a deeper look at each type.
Trinket Recipes (13 Total Trinkets)
To craft Trinkets, head to any Fence and trade the required materials along with a fee to craft the following 13 Trinkets. Each one provides a valuable boost that can improve your time in the game.
1. Beaver Tooth Trinket
- Effect: Permanently slows weapon degradation by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Beaver Tooth
- $18.25
2. Buck Antler Trinket
- Effect: Provides higher quality skinned animal parts.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Buck Antler
3. Cougar Fang Trinket
- Effect: Increases stamina experience bonus by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Cougar Fang
- $20.50
4. Coyote Fang Trinket
- Effect: Increases Dead Eye experience bonus by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Coyote Fang
- $21.50
5. Elk Antler Trinket
- Effect: Increases the value of looted money by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Elk Antler
6. Fox Claw Trinket
- Effect: Increases Eagle Eye duration by 5 seconds.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Fox Claw
7. Lion’s Paw Trinket
- Effect: Increases stamina experience bonus by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Lion’s Paw
- $19.75
8. Moose Antler Trinket
- Effect: Increases health experience bonus by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Moose Antler
- $19.00
9. Panther’s Eye Trinket
- Effect: Decreases the speed that Dead Eye drains by 10% for 3 seconds.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Panther Eye
- $24.50
10. Pronghorn Horn Trinket
- Effect: Increases stamina experience bonus by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Pronghorn Horn
- $25.00
11. Ram Horn Trinket
- Effect: Doubles the yield from Creeping Thyme, Oregano, and Wild Mint.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Ram Horn
12. Wolf Heart Trinket
- Effect: Doubles the amount of alcohol you can consume before feeling the effects of drunkenness.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Wolf Heart
13. Tatanka Bison Trinket
- Effect: Decreases melee damage taken by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Legendary Tatanka Bison Horn
Talismans (5 Total Talismans)
While Talismans are harder to craft and more expensive, they offer more substantial buffs. To create these, you’ll need a variety of special materials and pay a small fee. Here’s a breakdown of the 5 Talismans available.
1. Alligator Tooth Talisman
- Effect: Decreases the speed Dead Eye core drains by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Vintage Civil War Handcuffs
- 1x Gold Jointed Bracelet
- 1x Legendary Alligator Tooth
- $40.00
2. Bear Claw Talisman
- Effect: Decreases the speed health core drains by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Silver Chain Bracelet
- 1x Quartz Chunk
- 1x Legendary Bear Claw
- $34.75
3. Boar Tusk Talisman
- Effect: Decreases the speed that horse health and stamina cores drain by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Gold Earring
- 1x Cobalt Petrified Wood
- 1x Legendary Boar Tusk
- $31.00
4. Bison Horn Talisman
- Effect: Decreases the speed stamina core drains by 10%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Abalone Shell Fragment
- 1x Silver Earring
- 1x Legendary Bison Horn
- $38.50
5. Raven Claw Talisman
- Effect: Slows degradation of all weapons by 20%.
- How to Craft:
- 1x Old Brass Compass
- $29.00
Equipping Trinkets and Talismans

While Trinkets offer passive bonuses immediately after being crafted, Talismans are primarily for visual purposes. Trinkets automatically provide their respective buffs as soon as crafted, and you can view your active effects under Start > Player > General/Health/Stamina/Dead Eye > Perks.
Talismans, however, are more of a fashion statement. You can equip Talismans at your Wardrobe, but keep in mind that this will only change the appearance. The benefits provided by Talismans do not stack or alter when equipped, as they are applied automatically upon crafting.
Where to Find Fences
You can find Fences scattered across the world of Red Dead Redemption 2. Here are some key locations:
- Saint Denis – Located in the city, offering a wide selection of items.
- Rhodes – Situated on the outskirts of town.
- Emerald Ranch – A small shop tucked near the ranch.
- Van Horn Trading Post – One of the more secluded Fences.
Each Fence will have different stock, including Trinkets, Talismans, and other useful items.
Equipping Trinkets and Talismans can significantly boost your gameplay experience, making your character tougher and your adventures more efficient. Be sure to visit a Fence often to craft these powerful items and maximize your Red Dead Redemption 2 experience.
For more secrets and hidden gems in Red Dead Redemption 2, be sure to check out our guides on where to find the elusive Vampire, the 10 must-visit places, and all the details you need about the Panoramic Map. These will help you uncover even more of the game’s mysteries!
Thoughts on our Red Dead Redemption 2 Trinkets and Talismans guide? Drop them in the comments below.